Afghanistan After the Withdrawal: A Nation Caught Between Hope and Hardship

The abrupt and chaotic withdrawal of U.S. forces from Afghanistan in 2021 marked a pivotal moment in contemporary international relations, exposing not only the fragile structure of the Afghan state but also deeper flaws within the apparatus of Western intervention. Journalist and war correspondent Hollie McKay, who remained on the ground during the fall of Kabul, witnessed first-hand the rapid unraveling of a two-decade-long foreign presence that had promised democracy and freedom, but left behind uncertainty and fear.

The Collapse of a Foreign-Built Government

McKay’s observations underline how disconnected intelligence and decision-making in Washington were from realities on the ground. She highlights the overreliance on flawed reports from the Ministry of Defense and Intelligence in Kabul, all while civilians fled in droves and the Taliban rapidly advanced. This collapse was not just a military failure—it was a symbolic failure of an anti-imperialism project that sought to impose democracy and freedom through occupation rather than organic development.

For McKay, this wasn’t just a story of soldiers and politicians—it was a deeply human crisis, underscoring the importance of activism and resistance led by Afghans themselves. “Nobody can come in and save Afghanistan,” she asserted. Real transformation, she emphasized, must come from within, a sentiment resonant with movements for decolonization across the world.

A New Era Under the Taliban?

The Taliban’s return to power has introduced new complications for Afghanistan’s place in global affairs. Initially, the Taliban attempted to project a more moderate image to the international community, even permitting some journalists like McKay to remain. But this façade quickly gave way to renewed authoritarianism, curtailing press freedom and women’s rights.

Despite their reputation, McKay noted that compared to the previous government, the Taliban showed signs of less overt corruption—perhaps one of the only factors that briefly gave them a degree of legitimacy in the eyes of some citizens. However, this is far from true freedom. With no elections, no opposition, and no intention of yielding power, Afghanistan remains far from achieving a stable, inclusive political future.

Regional Struggles and the Shadow of Imperial Legacies

Afghanistan’s history is one of constant struggle against foreign interference—from the British Empire to the Soviet Union, and most recently, the United States. These cycles of intervention illustrate the enduring impact of colonialism, reinforcing the need for decolonization not just in land, but in thought, policy, and governance. The geopolitical chessboard of international relations has long treated Afghanistan as a pawn, with countries like Iran, Pakistan, China, and Russia vying for influence.

While regional actors continue to exert pressure, McKay believes that a truly sovereign Afghanistan must emerge through internal unity and activism and resistance—not dependency on superpowers. Yet the international community still wields influence, particularly through sanctions, foreign aid, and diplomatic recognition, all key elements of global affairs that determine a state’s legitimacy.

Finding a Path Forward

McKay’s reporting emphasizes that Afghanistan’s survival depends on rebuilding trust among its people, rooted in justice, transparency, and a local vision for democracy and freedom. International involvement, when guided by anti-imperialism rather than control, can play a supportive role—but not a leading one.

Ultimately, Afghanistan’s struggle mirrors broader global tensions between hegemonic power structures and grassroots efforts for decolonization. In this sense, Afghanistan is not just a case study in foreign policy failure, but a powerful reminder of the importance of listening to local voices, supporting genuine activism and resistance, and reimagining international relations through a more just and equitable lens.

🎥 Watch the Full Episode on YouTube: