India’s Military Miscalculation: A Strategic and Diplomatic Setback By Tafhim Kiani
The May 2025 conflict between India and Pakistan will likely be remembered as a watershed moment in South Asian military history. Far from intimidating Pakistan, India’s aggression has backfired spectacularly — exposing severe weaknesses in its armed forces, damaging the credibility of Western and Russian defence systems, and pushing the region closer to a China-led security bloc. India hasn’t just failed militarily; it has also undermined its geopolitical standing in the region and beyond.
Pakistan’s Tactical Superiority in the Air
Pakistan has claimed to have downed five Indian fighter jets in the latest confrontation, and this time the international media didn’t ignore it. Multiple sources, including CNN and aviation analysts, have confirmed that at least one French-made Rafale — one of the Indian Air Force’s crown jewels — was destroyed in combat.
The first Rafale to be lost in combat is a major embarrassment not only for India but for France, which has been aggressively marketing the jet worldwide. A detailed report by Army Recognition outlines this unprecedented event:
https://www.armyrecognition.com/news/aerospace-news/2025/breaking-news-first-french-rafale-fighter-jet-loss-pakistani-j-10c-from-china-may-have-used-pl-15-to-down-indian-rafale
The downings were executed by Pakistan’s newly deployed J-10C fighters — advanced Chinese jets that had never been tested in combat before. These jets, paired with the PL-15 long-range air-to-air missiles, are now being recognised by military observers as a game-changer. The War Zone describes the PL-15’s combat debut as a major development:
https://www.twz.com/air/chinas-pl-15-air-to-air-missile-appears-to-have-been-used-in-combat-for-first-time
Largest Air Battle Since WWII?
This confrontation is now being described by outlets like Newsweek as the largest state-on-state air battle since the Second World War — a staggering fact that underscores its historical significance:
https://www.newsweek.com/pakistan-india-jets-air-battle-china-rafale-1898123
Pakistan’s clear tactical advantage during this air battle contradicts the long-standing assumption of Indian air superiority and further damages India’s regional image.
A ‘DeepSeek Moment’ for Chinese Military Tech
Several defence analysts are calling this conflict a “DeepSeek moment” — likening it to the recent breakthroughs in AI, but for military technology. In this case, China appears to have achieved air superiority at a fraction of the cost of Western systems. What’s even more concerning for Western powers is that the J-10C is not even China’s most advanced platform. The Chinese air force still has the fifth-generation J-20 stealth fighter and the upcoming J-35 naval stealth jet in its arsenal.
Turkish and Israeli Drone Rivalry
The air war was not limited to fighter jets. Both sides deployed drones, with India using Israeli UAVs and Pakistan relying on Turkish platforms. Reports suggest that the Turkish drones outperformed expectations, proving more agile and harder to intercept — another blow to India’s reliance on Israeli and Western systems.
Electronic Warfare and the Fall of the S-400
Another damaging revelation was Pakistan’s reported destruction of a Russian-made S-400 air defence system at an Indian airbase. If confirmed, this will have severe implications for Russian arms exports, as the S-400 has been a flagship product. It also shows that expensive hardware from Russia and the West is becoming increasingly vulnerable to Chinese systems.
Chinese electronic warfare capabilities also played a vital role, reportedly jamming Indian communication channels and command networks during the conflict. This point has been explored by Eurasia Review in their broader coverage of Chinese electromagnetic warfare developments:
https://www.eurasiareview.com/11052025-weaponizing-the-electromagnetic-spectrum-the-chinas-high-powered-microwave-warfare-ambitions-analysis/
Geopolitical Isolation for India
The broader diplomatic fallout is equally severe for India. New Delhi’s aggressive stance has isolated it from many of its neighbours. Bangladesh, traditionally aligned with India, has started shifting its posture, rejecting India’s narrative and increasingly aligning with China and Pakistan. A recent editorial from The Sentinel Assam notes Bangladesh’s evolving stance:
https://www.sentinelassam.com/more-news/editorial/india-pakistan-tensions-and-bangladeshs-anti-indian-stance-safeguarding-the-northeast
This erosion of India’s neighbourhood dominance could have serious long-term implications. Meanwhile, Pakistan has solidified deeper military and political ties with China, Turkey, Azerbaijan, and now even Bangladesh.
The U.S. Strategy on India Faces a Setback
The United States has long relied on India as a counterbalance to China in Asia. But this conflict has made that strategy look increasingly flawed. India’s military failure, diplomatic isolation, and reliance on Western and Israeli technology that underperformed on the battlefield all suggest that India may not be the dependable partner Washington had hoped for.
China’s Strategic Opportunity
Finally, this war has handed China a golden opportunity. Not only has it successfully tested and proven its systems in real combat via Pakistan, but it has also gained crucial data on India’s operational weaknesses. China will undoubtedly use this information to refine its doctrine and hardware — further widening the technological gap in the years to come.
Conclusion: India’s Aggression Has Damaged Its Own Reputation
India’s military adventure in May 2025 will be remembered not as a show of strength, but as an act of overconfidence and miscalculation. Instead of subduing Pakistan, India has emboldened it. Instead of proving the worth of Western and Russian arms, it has cast doubt on them. And instead of solidifying its regional leadership, India has found itself more isolated than ever.
This conflict did not elevate India on the world stage — it exposed it.